About Me |
Name: Roya
Home: sydney, Australia
About Me: I went from looking for god to finding him evil to finding he does not exist, all before turning 14. Now, I can proudly say, I'm a libertarian, an anarchist, and a free thinker.
See my complete profile
|
Other Atheist Blogs |
Atheist Ethicist
Atheist Nation
Atheist Revolution
Babble, bullshit, blasphemy & being
Beep! Beep! It's Me
Beware of the God
Daylight Atheism
Debunking Christianity
Deep Thoughts
Drunken Tune
Evangelical Atheist
Friendly Atheist
God is for Suckers
Godless Wonder
Kill The Afterlife
Life, the Universe & Everything.
Meet An Atheist
My Case Against God
Neo Atheism
Stardust Musings and Thoughts for the Freethinker
Stupid Evil Bastard
The Atheist Jew
The Uncredible Hallq
The Wall of Separation
Unscrewing The Inscrutable
Way of the Mind
|
Science Blogs |
Bad Astronomy Blog
John Hawks Anthropology
Pharyngula
Scientia Natura: Evolution And Rationality
The Panda's Thumb
|
Blogs on Islamic Terrorism |
A Deeper Look
A New Dark Age Is Dawning
ANTI-DHIMMI
Apostates of Islam
Arabs for Israel
Campaign to Divest from "Palestine"
Cartoon Nazi
Eye On The World
Faithfreedom
History of Jihad
Jihad Watch
Little Green Footballs
Regime Change Iran
|
Atheist Resources |
PHILO (Atheist Philosophy Journal)
Atheist Resource
Bible & Christianity: Historical Origins
Biblical Nonsense
Creationism versus Science
The Complete Work of Charles Darwin
Evil Bible
God is Imaginary
No Answers In Genesis!
Philosophy of Religion
Positive Atheism
Sceptic's Annotated Bible
Strong Atheism
Talk.Origins Archive
The Jesus Puzzle
Theocracy Watch
Understanding Evolution
Web of Reason
|
Secular News Sources |
Internet Infidels News Wire
Religion News Service
The Revealer
|
Carnivals |
Humanist Symposium
The Carnival Of The Godless
Philosophers' Carnival
|
Forums |
Atheist Forums
Raving Atheists
Young Atheists Forum
|
Atheism on Audio |
Free Thought Radio
Hellbound Alleee
Infidel Guy Radio
Podcast Alley
|
Educational Video Clips |
Australian in Palestine account of child suicide bombers
Baptist Xian on Fox News
Does Religion Make You A Better Person?
Educated arabs discussing Bird Flu, Mad Cow disease and AIDS
Former Terrorists
G. Carlin: There is no God
G. Carlin: The 10 Cammandments
Hezbollywood - Beirut Reuters Photos fraud
Hezbollywood - CNN admits staging of photos by Hezbollah
Homosexuality and Morality
Homosexuality in Dolphins
Human Evolution: The Missing Link
Islamic Clerics Authorize Sexual Abuse of Children
Jesus Camp Trailer 1
Jesus Camp Trailer 2
Merry Mithras
Muslim Child abuse: Brainwashing
Muslim Child abuse: Glorifying Martydom
Muslim Child abuse: The 3 yr old girl
Muslims debate Sharia laws in Uk
Proving that the Bible is repulsive
Teaching Children to die for Allah in Palestine and Lebanon
Palestinian Suicide Terrorists Farewell Videos
Religious Delusion
Richard Dawkins BBC Interview
R. Dawkins: Speech in Kansas Uni.
Stupid design
The Bible Myth
"The God Who Wasn't There" Trailer
Wafa Sultan on Al Jazeera TV
Who wrote the bible?
Why atheists care about religion
|
For Fun |
Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster
Jesus' General
The Intelligent Designer Speaks
The Onion
|
Get Involved |
4Atheists
Active Atheism
Americans United
Atheist Activist
Atheist Alliance International
Atheists of Silicon Valley
Camp Quest
Center For Atheism
Center For Inquiry
Center For Naturalism
Coming Out Godless Project
Council for Secular Humanism
Freedom From Religion Foundation
Godless Americans PAC
Institute for Humanist Studies
International Humanist & Ethical Union
James Randi Education Foundation
Military Association of Atheists and Freethinkers
National Center for Science Education
Richard Dawkins Foundation for Reason and Science
Secular Coalition for America
Secular Earth
Secular Student Alliance
Skeptics Society
Talk Reason
The Secular Web
The Society for the Study of Evolution
|
Archives |
|
Buttons |
|
|
What do you think? |
Tuesday, May 09, 2006 |
Imagine there is someone in a hospital that needs blood transfusion to survive. He needs to get blood for nine months constantly without any stop. However he has a rear blood type and you are the only one who has the same blood type as his. As he would die without you, you are forced to give blood constantly to him. You would loose a lot of nutrition and your body would not look as young as it would if you did not have to give your blood. You would also have more chance of osteoporosis (later in old age) and of a more severe type. However, your act would give life to someone else. Should you be forced to do so?
I'm curious why no "pro-lifer" ever advocates such things except when it comes to abortion? Why aren't we forced to give blood or a kidney or to adopt street kids, if these are needed to save lifes? Why do they pro-lifers have a problem with bringing a new life to this world to save an existing life?
I also have found another version of the same problem, which you may like better. |
posted by Roya @ 5:28 AM |
|
7 Comments: |
-
I have asked people these same questions and never get a clear answer. One time at a gas station I noticed a large sticker on the vehicle that was parked in front of mine and the owner of that vehicle was pumping gas. The bumper sticker was a pro-life message with a picture of a fetus on it and it said "Mothers, This Is Your Son". I thought that was very heartless to have on display since there are so many women in the world who have endured the heartbreak of miscarriage, and for some women who have gone through the emotional pain that comes with having an abortion. Anyway, I could not help myself. I asked this man "So, How many unwanted children have you adopted?" He said "I beg your pardon?" I repeated the question and he told me "It is none of your business." I told him that a woman's uterus is none of his business either.
Some pro-lifers do practice what they preach and have adopted and helped desperate pregnant women and their children, and some do give blood, and others kidneys etc...but most just want to preach and tell people how to live without HELPING them to live.
-
Vaghat mikhastam begam salam.
Filip unitedfreethinkers.com
-
I understand stardust. Some religious people can be good as well. The problem is that going through pregnancy is not that easy.
If someone wants to adopt, it is their choice, but trying to force someone to go through pregnancy against their own will is not a chioce is it?
There are many orphants in the world that need to be adopted or helped in someway or another in order to survive. What I don't get is why those pro-lifers who want to force women to give birth by changing the law, don't advocate changes to the law so that everyone has to adopt at least one child to help those lifes to survive. If they are true pro-lifers that's what they would have done.
If a women can be forced to give life, others should be forced to help as well. Otherwise, we are saying that it is the women's fault she is pregnant, so she has to pay for it.
-
-
J, what I meant was that forcing a woman to give birth is just the same as forcing people to adopt kids. A pro-lifer could not choose between the two and the fact that they only support the first one, shows that their motive is religiously based and has nothing to do with valuing life itself.
I agree with you that they are not pro-lifers and that's the point that I wanted to make (I guess I didn't succeed in that :( ).
-
Thanks for the link to my Blog & adding me to your Blogroll. I have returned the compliment.
-
If someone wants to adopt, it is their choice, but trying to force someone to go through pregnancy against their own will is not a chioce is it?
I agree with what you are saying. If pro-lifers started adopting babies they would feel justified further to tell a pregnant woman she cannot have an abortion. So...I guess I won't be asking pro-lifers that question anymore! I don't want to give them any ideas!
My anger towards pro-lifers is that they are all talk and no action. They could contribute time to Planned Parenthood and help educate young people about safe sex and birth control. But many of them don't want to even talk about that.
But that goes back to fundamentalists being against education.
|
|
<< Home |
|
|
|
|
Action Alerts |
Stop Unnecessary and Misleading House Resolution
“American Religious History Week” Resolution Gives the Wrong Impression about Religion in the U.S.
ACT NOW!
|
Proudly Support |
|
Search |
|
Recommended Books |
|
Must See List of DVDs |
|
|
I have asked people these same questions and never get a clear answer. One time at a gas station I noticed a large sticker on the vehicle that was parked in front of mine and the owner of that vehicle was pumping gas. The bumper sticker was a pro-life message with a picture of a fetus on it and it said "Mothers, This Is Your Son". I thought that was very heartless to have on display since there are so many women in the world who have endured the heartbreak of miscarriage, and for some women who have gone through the emotional pain that comes with having an abortion.
Anyway, I could not help myself. I asked this man "So, How many unwanted children have you adopted?" He said "I beg your pardon?" I repeated the question and he told me "It is none of your business." I told him that a woman's uterus is none of his business either.
Some pro-lifers do practice what they preach and have adopted and helped desperate pregnant women and their children, and some do give blood, and others kidneys etc...but most just want to preach and tell people how to live without HELPING them to live.